Rouse Outdoors
Check out our social media
  • Home
  • Videos
  • News
  • Resources
    • Heated docks in Kansas
  • Contact Us
  • Partner Sites
  • Chatroom
  • Photos
    • Hunting Photos
    • Fishing Photos
    • Weather Photos
    • Scenery Photos

Kansan seeking change after finding mutilated deer on state-owned property

8/30/2016

1 Comment

 
Picture
Submitted photo
Originally printed in The Topeka Capital-Journal

​A Labette County man stumbled upon a startling scene this week on state property — and now he is pushing for change.


Robert Broadway, of Altamont, said he was walking down the road Aug. 23 near 17500 and Douglas Road on the Big Hill Wildlife Unit when he discovered five mutilated deer carcasses that had been left to rot on state-owned land. Each deer had only its backstrap, a loin of meat consisting of the muscle on each side of the spine, removed before being dumped.
Broadway, angered by the wasteful killings, believed a local landowner used a deer predation permit — a common source of tension between hunters and farmers — to legally slaughter the deer.
Picture
Submitted photo
“Vehicle access to this location is through a locked gate,” Broadway said in an email to the Kansas Department of Wildlife, Parks and Tourism. “The general public cannot drive to this location. Only the adjacent landowners have the keys. Furthermore, I think these deer were shot on a KWPT food (clover) plot.”
​

Game warden Jeremy Stenstrom, who investigated the scene the next day, noted his disgust with the incident in an email to The Topeka Capital-Journal. He said the photographs were “unfortunately a scene that I and my fellow Game Wardens find disturbing and give the law-abiding sportsman a bad reputation.”

Broadway further described the scene in his email to the KDWPT.

“You could clearly see where a truck had backed up,” Broadway wrote. “There were two pools of blood in the road. The deer were slit up the back in the back of the truck, the backstraps removed, and then they were dumped out. You could see where the truck pulled away. These people were not in a hurry. They felt safe. This looks like a landowner behind a locked gate with a depredation permit to me.”

A depredation permit, which Broadway likened to legalized poaching when misused, is issued to landowners — often farmers looking to protect their crops from deer — to take a set number of deer on their land or nearby properties. The KDWPT also stipulates on its website that landowners who are issued the permits must agree to allow firearms deer hunting on their property during the year’s regular or extended firearms season, though hunter access is at the landowner’s discretion.

In an Aug. 24 email to The Capital-Journal, Broadway detailed his frustrations with the state’s policy regarding depredation permits.

“The questions that need to be asked are: How many deer in Kansas are being harvested legally, but ‘out of season’ by farmers and why are farmers allowed to treat depredation-killed deer like garbage?” he wrote. “Why are they not required to process the deer? This is a case of flagrant wanton waste and apparently, it’s legal. That fact is going to infuriate hunters in Kansas.”

He said several of the does had full milk sacks, meaning some fawns likely were orphaned by the wasteful killing.

“Without a requirement to process the harvest, we can assume much is wasted,” Broadway said. “As a policy consideration, at a minimum, why is there not a requirement to donate the meat to a food bank?”

While Broadway pushed for policy change surrounding the depredation permits — even going as far as to contact the governor’s office — some state officials urged restraint.

Rep. Ken Corbet, R-Topeka, said the matter was “highly susceptible to inflammatory rhetoric and opinions from all sides,” and as such he said it wouldn’t be appropriate to offer his opinion on the case until the investigation had concluded.

“That said, depredation permits are a legitimate use of wildlife management, and when responsibly used in adherence with Kansas law, they can be an effective tool to help control crop damage as well as loss of life, property damage and injury in instances of deer/motor vehicle accidents,” said Corbet, who also owns and operates the Ravenwood Lodge hunting resort in Topeka. “As a sportsman, I do not condone the wanton waste of game.”

Lloyd Fox, big game program coordinator for the KDWPT, oversees the depredation program. He said area wildlife managers typically produce excellent habitat, and many of the areas have high densities of deer. Occasionally, he said, crop damage occurs near lands the agency manages even though it allows open hunter access.

“Our employees would always prefer that hunters took the excess deer in a population and that they followed fair chase with high ethical standards, as well as used and shared the meat from the animals they kill to its maximum,” Fox said.

However, he said depredation isn’t considered recreational or “fair-chase” hunting, but rather a tool to cull deer to manage their numbers. In Kansas, deer are considered a natural resource, and deer populations are managed through a variety of tactics by the KDWPT.

“We are frequently caught between landowners with conflicting objectives,” Fox said. “That includes landowners growing crops and hunters and landowners growing deer.”

Tim Donges, president of the Quality Deer Management Association’s Bluestem branch in El Dorado, said he understood the challenges involved with balancing the needs of farmers with the needs of hunters and non-hunters. He said the KDWPT and farmers should “exhaust efforts” for the meat to be utilized in some form or to allow some type of doe harvest to occur on and around the property if needed.

“To be honest, the non-hunting public, along with a lot of hunters, would have a serious fit if they knew KDWPT and farmers were shooting deer and letting them be wasted,” Donges said. “At the end of the day, KDWPT and farmers need to be very careful about our conservation image to the public.”

Donges recalled a situation he witnessed where a farmer in West Virginia had shot more than 100 deer next to a public hunting area and left them where they lay. However, he said, the main rifle season the year before had been canceled because of an extreme natural disaster.

Both Donges and the KDWPT agreed that deer depredation permits were at best a short-term solution and more extensive management techniques are needed in the long term. Donges suggested setting up a Quality Deer Management Cooperative — a group of landowners and hunters working together to improve the quality of deer herds and hunting experiences — in the area to manage the deer population.

However, numbers from a KDWPT report show farmers may already be taking a different tact regarding deer population management.

According to the report, the issuance of depredation permits by the agency in recent years is actually down substantially from the program’s inception in 1999, though still higher than its lowest point in 2004, when only 39 permits were issued. At its peak in 2000, the program issued 284 permits, resulting in between 700 and 800 deer kills. In 2015, just 57 permits were issued — down from 129 in 2010 and 90 in 2013 — and about 150 deer were killed.

The report also shows the harvest of deer by hunters during the 2015-16 seasons was estimated to be 95,813 deer. That number is 2 percent more than the previous year, and of those 23 percent of the hunters were nonresidents.

Fox said the department typically limits the permits it issues to white-tailed deer and antlerless deer, and he deferred to local KDWPT employees who were investigating this individual case.

While Stenstrom said he couldn’t discuss the case until charges had been filed, he applauded Broadway’s efforts to bring the incident to light.

“Through the vigilance of Mr. Broadway, this is an incident where the facts and all competent evidence can be analyzed thoroughly,” Stenstrom said. “Mr. Broadway has shown a great passion in assisting with the investigation and should be commended by all sportsmen in his fight against the unjustice of violating wildlife law.”

KDWPT Secretary Robin Jennison, who was emailed regarding the department’s policies on the wanton waste of wildlife, hadn’t responded at the time of publication.

More information on QDM Cooperatives can be found at http://tinyurl.com/guokh2u/.
To be honest, the non-hunting public, along with a lot of hunters, would have a serious fit if they knew KDWPT and farmers were shooting deer and letting them be wasted,” Donges said. “At the end of the day, KDWPT and farmers need to be very careful about our conservation image to the public.”
1 Comment
https://archeryview.com/ link
8/16/2018 06:59:13 am

Once you own a property you should be talking to the person that has been concern to the one you are talking about it. When there is a selective time for the deer hunting it is the one thing that has been discussed firmly.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Picture

    Author

    Josh Rouse is an outdoor enthusiast from Topeka, Kansas. He is the Outdoors Editor for The Topeka Capital-Journal.

    View my profile on LinkedIn

    Archives

    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    August 2016
    May 2016
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    March 2015
    October 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    February 2014
    August 2013
    April 2012
    January 2012
    November 2011
    September 2011
    August 2011
    July 2011
    June 2011
    May 2011

    Categories

    All
    Abu Garcia
    Alabama
    Alaska
    All American Catfish Tournaments
    All-American Catfish Tournaments
    Angler Feature
    Apps
    Aqua Vu
    Aqua-Vu
    Arbogast
    Archery
    Arkansas
    ATVs
    Audubon Society
    Backlashers Bass Club
    Badger
    Bald Eagles
    Barbel
    Bass
    Bassmaster
    Bass Pro Shops
    Bear
    Benelli
    Berkley
    Big Bucks
    Big Cats
    Big Game
    Big Horned Sheep
    Big-horned Sheep
    Bird Watching
    Bison
    Boar
    Boating
    Books
    Booyah
    Bosnia
    Bow Fishing
    Bow Hunting
    B&P Jighead
    Brandon Palaniuk
    Browning
    Bullfrogs
    Burbot
    Business
    Buzzbaits
    Cabela's
    Calendar
    California
    Camping
    Canada
    CarbonTV
    Carp
    Catfish
    Catfish Chasers
    Catfish Weekly
    Chubs
    College Fishing
    Colorado
    Connecticut
    Conservation
    Cougars
    Country Stampede
    Coyotes
    Cranes
    Crankbaits
    Crappie
    Crappie Masters
    Creeks
    Critters
    Culprit
    Cycling
    Daiwa
    Deer
    Dogs
    Doug Vahrenberg
    Doves
    Drum
    Ducks
    Ducks Unlimited
    Eagle Claw
    Education
    Elk
    Environment
    Europe
    Fall
    Fireworks
    Fishing
    Fishing's Future
    Fish Stories
    FleFly
    Fle Fly
    Fle-Fly
    Flint Hills Bass Association
    Florida
    FLW
    Fly Fishing
    Frogs
    Fur Harvesting
    Gander Mountain
    Gar
    Geese
    Georgia
    Government
    Great Plains Nature Center
    Grilling
    Gulf Of Mexico
    Guns
    Hawaii
    Health
    Heartland Bowhunter
    Heddon
    Henry Repeating Arms
    Heroes On The Water
    Hiking
    Humminbird
    Humor
    Hunters For Life
    Hunting
    Hunting Shows
    ICAST
    Ice Fishing
    Idaho
    Illinois
    In Fisherman
    In-Fisherman
    Insects
    Instagram
    Invasive Species
    Iowa
    Jackson Kayaks
    Joey Nania
    Kansas
    Kansas Crappie Club
    Kansas Crappie Trail
    Kansas Herpetological Society
    Kansas Wetlands Education Center
    Kayaking
    Kentucky Lake
    K State
    K-State
    Lake Of The Ozarks
    Lakes
    Lake Trout
    Lake Wheeler
    Lazy Ikes
    Lightning Photos
    Little Cleos
    Louisiana
    Lure Lock
    Lures
    Mackerel
    Mahi Mahi
    Mahi-Mahi
    Marcum
    Maryland
    Melvern Reservoir
    Memories
    Michigan
    Micro Fishing
    Micro-fishing
    Midwest Finesse
    Milford Nature Center
    Milford Reservoir
    Mille Lacs
    Minnesota
    Mississippi
    Missouri
    Montana
    Moose
    Mountain Lions
    Mr. Crappie
    Mushrooms
    Music
    Muskie
    Muzzleloaders
    Nace
    National Park Service
    Nature
    Nebraska
    Ned Kehde
    Ned Rig
    Neko Rig
    Nevada
    New Jersey
    News
    Newspapers
    New York
    Night Fishing
    Noodling
    North Carolina
    North Dakota
    Northern Pike
    NRA
    NWTF
    Ohio
    Oklahoma
    Old Reel Collectors Association
    Oregon
    Paddlefish
    Panfish
    Pennsylvania
    Pflueger
    Pheasants
    Pheasants Forever
    Pond Management
    Ponds
    Prairie Chickens
    Predators
    Pro Cure
    Pro-Cure
    Published
    Q&A
    Quail
    Quail Forever
    QUWF
    Rage Tail
    Ranger
    Rapala
    Reading
    Rebel Lures
    Records
    Redfish
    Reviews
    Rivers
    Roach
    Rose Kuli
    Safaris
    Safety
    Salmon
    Saltwater Fishing
    Sauger
    Saugeye
    Sharks
    Shimano
    Shotguns
    Slovenia
    Smallmouth Buffalo
    Smelt
    Snakes
    Snapper
    South Africa
    South America
    South Carolina
    South Dakota
    Species Feature
    Spiderwire
    Spring
    Spring Turkey
    SPRO
    Storm Lures
    Storms
    Sturgeon
    Sufix
    Summer
    Summertime
    Sutherlands
    Sweetwater TV
    Table Rock Lake
    Tackle
    Taxidermy
    Tennessee
    Terminator
    Texas
    Tightlines UV
    Toledo Bend
    Topeka
    Top Secret Jig Co.
    Topwater
    Tornado
    Tournament Fishing
    Trail Camera
    Trapping
    Trapshooting
    Trent Siegle
    Trilene
    Trout
    TTG Lures
    Turkey
    United States
    Upland Birds
    Varmint
    Veterans
    Vibe Kayaks
    Vibric
    Video Games
    Vintage Lures
    Virginia
    VMC
    Walleye
    Washburn
    Washburn Review
    Washington State
    Waterfowl
    Weather
    Westar Energy
    Westin Fishing
    West Virginia
    Wetlands
    White Bass
    Wild Game
    WILD Kansas
    Wilson Lake
    Winter
    Wiper
    Wisconsin
    Wyoming
    Yakima
    Youth
    YouTube
    YO ZURI
    YO-ZURI
    Zebco
    Z Man
    Z-Man
    Zoom

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly